Anti-Capitalist Conservative, but I am Still Against Universal Basic Income
On municipal housing, I am fully on board with updating zoning, using Landlord Licensing to keep bad-faith landlords accountable, waiving development charges for affordable builds, allocating federal housing grants to non-profits, and donating surplus city land to community land trusts. When it comes to urban growth and local democracy, establishing density corridors in Downtown Kitchener, mandating family-sized three-bedroom units along transit lines, and protecting local decision-making against forced provincial boundary expansions are all priorities I strongly support.
My background working on farms makes me what I call an "Alberta conservative," which in practice means I am deeply committed to conservation and protecting our land. I am completely opposed to data centers because we must protect our groundwater, agricultural soil, and local wildlife from noise pollution, not to mention the massive water footprint they create. On Council, I will enforce strict zoning performance standards, expand our urban tree canopy, and protect our municipal utilities. On food security, I back expanding urban agriculture zoning, funding community gardens, supporting the Kitchener Market, and stopping urban sprawl on farmland. I would love to know if there are other specific steps you would like me to champion beyond those.
The one major area where we part ways is Universal Basic Income, and I want to be direct with you about why. I know UBI started as a genuinely noble idea, from Martin Luther King Jr.’s calls for economic security to early progressive proposals. Perhaps it should have been passed in the 1960s, or during the 2008 recession instead of giving bailout checks to banks. But today, the UBI movement has been completely hijacked by tech oligarchs like Elon Musk, Sam Altman, and Chris Hughes, with capitalist liberals playing right along.
Modern UBI has turned into a Trojan Horse designed to dismantle the actual social safety net. Under these tech-libertarian proposals, cash payouts are used as an excuse to privatize public services, healthcare, housing, and education. If basic necessities remain privatized, a flat monthly check just gets swallowed up by corporate landlords, tech monopolies, and private healthcare providers, leaving working families with no real financial security compared to universal public services.
This brings me back to why I fight against AI data centers: the real threat facing working people is the concentration of AI, land, data, and technology in the hands of a tiny corporate elite. Under the tech billionaire vision of UBI, citizens receive just enough cash to pay monthly subscription fees back to the very monopolies that automated their jobs. Once workers lose their jobs to AI, they lose their power to organize, strike, and demand better conditions. Instead of worker power and human dignity, you end up with elite benevolence, where a permanent working class is pacified by an allowance while the top 0.01% consolidates total political and economic control.
I know your heart is in the right place, and I deeply respect your dedication to Waterloo Region. But I believe UBI as it exists today cannot be rescued from the tech billionaires who co-opted it; it can only be rejected in favor of strong public services, worker power, and local economic control. I look forward to working together on housing, environmental protection, and local governance where our goals line up.


Comments